top of page

BITTER CHRISTMAS

Colin Fraser
5 hours ago
2 min read

THREE STARS A film director with writer's block mines the lives his friends to tell a story about a film director with writer's block.

DRAMA SPAIN Spanish #BITTERCHRISTMAS Starring Leonardo Sbaraglia, Bárbara Lennie



Pedro Almodóvar has never been particularly shy about putting himself into his films. BITTER CHRISTMAS finds the director at his most introspective as he disappears down an increasingly elaborate rabbit hole that questions the questionable business of artists making art out of the lives of those closest to them. It's engaging if not Pedro at his most engaging. Indeed most of us are left wondering if all this introspection is all that healthy. Or maybe that’s the point.


Elsa (Bárbara Lennie) is in a tailspin following the death of her mother during the Christmas holidays. Work becomes a convenient distraction, until a health crisis forces her to take a break. She heads to Lanzarote with her friend Patricia (Victoria Luengo) where the volcanic landscape provides a suitably dramatic backdrop for grief, complicated friendships and the sort of personal revelations that tend to emerge when people self-isolate. Her relationship with the much younger Bonifacio (Patrick Criado), a fireman who sidelines as a male stripper, also hits some rocks.


Yet there's another story unfolding. Filmmaker Raúl (Leonardo Sbaraglia) is struggling with writer's block and a troubled screenplay that lacks inspiration. Gradually, we discover that his script is, in fact, Elsa's story. Characters and their circumstances are drawn from the lives of those around him, including long-time assistant Mónica (Aitana Sánchez-Gijón) and his own, long-suffering partner Santi. Parallels between Raúl the filmmaker and his screenplay filmmaker (much less Almodovar the filmmaker) become increasingly apparent, raising the uncomfortable question of just how much artistic licence an artist should be entitled to exercise when the raw material belongs to someone else.


Intriguing, up to a point.


As always, Almodóvar's staging is immaculate. The interiors are gorgeous, the compositions considered and the colours wonderfully controlled. There's rarely a frame that hasn’t been art-directed to within an inch of its life. Unfortunately, the same attention isn't always applied to the dialogue. As with many of the director’s more recent films, BITTER CHRISTMAS is something of a yak-a-thon with characters explaining, discussing and reflecting upon things that might be considerably more impactful if simply allowed to happen. A little less tell and a lot more show would help enormously.


Which leaves you wondering what the point is exactly. Be nice and don’t plunder your friends lives for an artistic hit? It’s not the most compelling reason to head to the cinema. That said, if you're going to spend a couple of hours hanging out in the ultra-meta world of an artist contemplating himself as an artist, you could certainly do worse than spend it with these people. However, at the risk of sounding, ahem, bitter, if this all sounds like way too much self-indulgent naval gazing, you can always revisit PARALLEL MOTHERS for a comparable, spirited reminder of Almodóvar's considerable gifts.


 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page